OUTCOMES
Outcome a - graduates are well-prepared in application of mathematics, sciences and engineering to solve mining engineering related problems

    Goal 1
  • Our graduates understand and are able to apply engineering fundamentals, mathematics and sciences to solve mining problems.

    Performance Criteria
      1) define problems
      2) sketch physical situation
      3) define unknowns
      4) find missing information/data
      5) solve problems

      Practices
          • problems
          • exams
          • design projects

      Measures
        faculty assessment of:
          • problem assignments
          • exams
          • design projects

      Feedback
          • to students on all assignments
          • to faculty, particularly from senior design projects

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates who are pursuing a mining engineering career are encouraged to take the Fundamentals of Engineering(FE) examination

    Performance Criteria
      1) Students will take FE Examination

      Practices
          • students are encouraged to take FE examination
          • problem sets in associated subjects
          • review of typical FE problems by college faculty

      Measures
          • statistics provided by state board

      Feedback
          • to faculty from statistics
Outcome b - graduates are well-prepared to conduct experiments, as well as to analyze and interpret data,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates are well prepared to conduct experiments.

    Performance Criteria
      1) understanding the significance of individual components
      2) synthesize these components to complete experimental circuit.
      3) conducting experiments

      Practices
          • laboratory projects
      Measures
        faculty assessment of:
          • laboratory projects

      Feedback
          • to students from all laboratory projects • to faculty from performance

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates have analyzed and interpreted data

    Performance Criteria
      1) solve sequence of simpler problems
      2) analyze and interpret data

      Practices
          • synthesize into solution of complex problems

      Measures
        faculty assessment of:
          • laboratory projects

      Feedback
          • to students from all laboratory projects
          • to faculty
          • particularly from senior design project
Outcome c - graduates are well-prepared to design a system, component, or process to meet desired needs,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates have an understanding of the individual functions of the subsystems of a particular mine system and their relationship to the overall mine system.

    Performance Criteria
      1) analysis of performance of existing sub-systems
      2) understand interrelationship between sub-systems in complex mine plan

      Practices
          • problem sets
          • exams
          • design problem sets
          • field observations

      Measures
        Faculty assessment of:
          • problem sets
          • exams
          • design problem sets

      Feedback
          • to students on all assignments • to faculty, particularly from mining major

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates are well prepared to design individual components of a particular mine system to meet desired goal.

    Performance Criteria
      1) design of individual mine element
      2) understanding interrelationship between sub-system in complex mine plans

      Practices
          • design problem sets
          • field observations

      Measures
        faculty assessment of:
          • overall presentation
          • written project
          • rubric evaluation of design projects

      Feedback
          • to students on the design project
          • to faculty, particularly from senior design projects

Outcome d - graduates have an ability to function on multi-disciplinary teams.
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates have experience working in teams that are either major or multi-disciplinary.

    Performance Criteria
      1) divide work appropriately/evenly
      2) timely completion of work
      3) respect and include views of all members
      4) produce product content exceeding that which an individual group member could produce individually

      Practices
          • design projects
          • mine survey
          • laboratory
          • year-long, senior design project

      Measures
          • self-assessment of design projects and laboratory experiments
          • alumni self-assessment
          • employer assessment

      Feedback
          • to students from all projects and laboratory experiments
Outcome e - graduates have an ability to identify, formulate, and solve engineering problems,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates have an ability to formulate and solve the engineering problems.

    Performance Criteria
      1) analysis of performance of existing elements
      2) identify substandard performance
      3) design of individual mine elements

      Practices
          • problem sets
          • exams
          • design problem sets
          • field observations<br>
      Measures
        Faculty assessment of:
          • problem sets
          • exams
          • design projects

      Feedback
          • to students from all projects
          • to faculty, particularly from senior design projects<br>
    Goal 2
    o Our graduates are able to apply economic and physical constraints as well as optimization methods to arrive at an effective solution.

    Performance Criteria
      1) use economics to drive solution to problem
      2) define objective function
      3) define decision variables
      4) use optimization methods to find solution

      Practices
          • design projects

      Measures
        faculty assessment of:
          • design projects

      Feedback
          • to students from all projects
          • to faculty, particularly from senior design project

    Goal 3
    o Our graduates are able to solve complex problems by resolving them into solvable engineering sub-systems.

    Performance Criteria
      1) identify road map of a complex mine system
      2) identify physical subsystem and economical constraints of the subsystem
      3) use optimization or computer aided design process

      Practices
          • problem sets
          • exams
          • design problem sets
          • field observations

      Measures
        Faculty assessment of:
          • problem sets
          • exams
          • design projects

      Feedback
          • to students on all assignments
          • to faculty, particularly from mining majors

Outcome f - graduates have an understanding of professional and ethical responsibility,
    Goal 1
    o Our students participate in professional societies meetings and the student chapter of the society for Mining, Metallurgy & Exploration Engineers for better understanding of professionalisms.

    Performance Criteria
      1) students participate inone national and two regional SME meetings per academic year

      Practices
          • practical observation of mining engineer during the meetings
          • discussion with industrial people
          • participating with students of other institution in student activities

      Measures
          • industrial evaluation of the student

      Feedback
          • to the students by department chairman

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates have familiarity with codes of ethics.

    Performance Criteria
      1) students will confront their own values via case studies discussed in class
      2) students will be able to differentiate between ethical and legal issues

      Practices
          • class discussion, case studies, and videos in design class
      Measures
          • faculty evaluation of classroom discussion
          •student self-assessment
          • alumni self-assessment

      Feedback
          • to students during all classroom exercises
          • to faculty from classroom exercises

    Goal 3
    o Our graduates demonstrate appropriate ethical behavior while students at WVU.

    Performance Criteria
      1) students will follow the rules on the majors, exams, and all other assignments
      2) students will behave appropriately while doing group work

      Practices
          • conduct in groups during design projects
          • conduct while doing majors
          • conduct in year-long, senior design project

      Measures
          • faculty evaluation of student behavior
          • student self-assessment

      Feedback
          • to faculty from all projects
          • to students, if warranted

Outcome g - graduates have ability to communicate effectively,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates are able to organize an oral presentation and present it in a professional manner.

    Performance Criteria
      1) prepare effective slides
      2) effective delivery (eye contact, well-organized)
      3) good physical explanations
      4) tell complete story
      5) good response to questions

      Practices
          • design projects
          • laboratory presentations

      Measures
          • faculty and peer assessment of:
          • design projects
          • laboratory reports
          • employer assessment

      Feedback
          • to students from all projects and laboratory experiments
          • to faculty, particularly from senior design project

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates are able to prepare a well written technical reports according to the prescribed format.

    Performance Criteria
      1) correct grammar
      2) correct punctuation
      3) correct format
      4) correct spelling
      5) logical organization
      6) good physical explanations
      7) valid documentation
      8) tell complete story
      9) aesthetically pleasing figures and tables

      Practices
          • design projects
          • laboratory presentations

      Measures
        faculty assessment of:
          • design projects
          • laboratory reports
          • employer assessment

      Feedback
          • to students from all projects and laboratory experiments
          • to faculty, particularly from senior design project

 

Outcome h - graduates have the broad education necessary to understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global and societal context,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates have an understanding of the social and global impacts of mining.

    Performance Criteria
      1) understand mining and post mining land management
      2) environmental awareness
      3) understanding of waste disposal methods
      4) understanding post mining reclamatiion

      Practices
          • integration into all classes
          • liberal studies program

      Measures
          • student self-assessment
          • faculty assessment of design projects
          • alumni self-assessment

      Feedback
          • to faculty from self-assessment instruments

Outcome i – graduates have a recognition of the need for, and an ability to engage in life-long learning,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates are aware of the need for life long learning as demonstrated by their knowledge of rapidly changing mining technology they have seen on mine visits and work experiences.

    Performance Criteria
      1) learn about new technology
      2) do more sophisticated analyses than done in class

      Practices
          • year-long, senior design project
          • mine visits
          • summer job or CO-Op

      Measures
          • faculty assessment and student self-assessment
          • alumni self-assessment
          • employer assessment

      Feedback
          • to faculty from all group projects and assessment instruments

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates are familiar with career opportunities and lifelong learning experiences such as graduate school and continuing education.

    Performance Criteria
      1) use career services
      2) those interested demonstrate familiarity with professional/graduate school opportunities
      3) alumni participation in continuing education

      Practices
          • SME student chapter meetings and field observations.
          • class discussions

      Measures
          • student self-assessment
          • alumni self-assessment

      Feedback
          • to faculty from all self-assessment instruments

    Goal 3
    o Our graduates are encouraged to attend professional meetings.

    Performance Criteria
      1) students participate in SME annual meetings
      2) students participate in two regional SME meetings per year (i.e., PCMI/SME and WVCMI/SME)

      Practices
          • Students are encouraged to participate in professional meetings and financial support is provided by the college.
      Measures
          • 35 - 50% of student participation
          • industry recognition

      Feedback
          • to faculty

    Goal 4
    o Our graduates have found information outside of class and applied it to class problems.

    Performance Criteria
      1) learn about equipment other than those taught in class
      2) do more sophisticated analyses than done in class

      Practices
          • year-long, senior design project
          • design projects
          • subscription to the mining engineering magazine
          • obtain mining equipment catalogues

      Measures
          • faculty and self-assessment of year-long senior design project
          • faculty assessment of subsystem design project
          • faculty assessment of laboratory experiments
          • self-assessment in laboratory class
          • alumni self-assessment
          • employer assessment

      Feedback
          • to students from all projects and laboratory experiments

Outcome j - graduates have knowledge of contemporary issues,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates understand the impact of government regulations and public policy on engineering practice.

    Performance Criteria
      1) understand government regulations
      2) understand environmental laws
      3) understand need for public awareness
      4) understand legal vs. ethical responsibilities

      Practices
          • integration into all classes
          • liberal studies program

      Measures
          • student self-assessment
          • alumni self-assessment

      Feedback
          • to faculty from self-assessment instruments

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates have practical mining engineering experience.

    Performance Criteria
      1) students have summer jobs with mining industry
      2) students may choose to participate in CO-Op program practices

      Practices
          • practical experience of mining operation

      Measures
          • industrial evaluation of the student

      Feedback
          • to the students by department chairman

    Goal 3
    o Our graduates have knowledge of contemporary mining related technologies and systems.

    Performance Criteria
      1) Sub-system design
      2) understand interrelationship between sub-systems and complex mine plan
      3) modification of the sub-systems or complex mine plan for implementation of contemporary issues.

      Practices
          • mining engineering publication and journals
          • equipment manufacturing catalogs
          • visit of mining equipment manufacturing companies
          • problem sets
          • design project
          • field observation
          • seminars by industrial specialists

      Measures
        Faculty assessment of:
          • problem sets
          • design projects

      Feedback
          • to the students on all assignments
          • to faculty, particularly from mining majors

    Goal 4
    o Our graduates are introduced to current mining issues in different forms of public media such as current articles, documentaries and litigation.

    Performance Criteria
      1) Demonstrate knowledge of current mining issues in planning mine design
      2) apply current issues in selecting mining methods/equipment

      Practices
          • problems assigned
          • design projects

      Measures
        Faculty assessment of
          • problem assignment
          •design projects

      Feedback
          • to the students from all assignments

    Goal 5
    o Our graduates participate in field trips.

    Performance Criteria
      1) SME student chapter participates in 8 – 10 field trips/year
      2) apply field information to problem assignments

        Practices
        • students are encouraged to participate as many as possible field trips

    Measures
        • 30 - 50% students participate in field trips
        • industry recognition

    Feedback
        • to the department chair

Outcome k - graduates have an ability to use the techniques, skills, and modern engineering tools necessary for engineering practice,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates are proficient in at least one operating system(such as windows), one office suite (word processor, spreadsheet, presentation) and mining application software packages (such as Vnet PC, conveyor belt, ALPS or STOP).

    Performance Criteria
    1) solve problems using software
    2) prepare written reports
    3) make slides for presentations

    Practices
        • problem sets
        • design projects
        • laboratory reports

    Measures
      faculty assessment of:
        • problem assignments
        • design projects
        • laboratory reports

    Feedback
        • to students from all assignments

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates have the ability to use computer-based information systems such as the World Wide Web, government data bases, online equipment manufacturing data, and information systems found in the libraries.

    Performance Criteria
      1) proficient in using the world wide web to find information
      2) access information data bases such as those in system optimization
      3) use library data bases

      Practices
          • year-long, senior design project
          • design projects

      Measures
          • faculty assessment of year-long senior design project
          • student and alumni self-assessment

      Feedback
      • to students from all projects

Outcome l – graduates have an understanding of the importance of economics, environment, health and safety issues in the design and operations of modern mines,
    Goal 1
    o Our graduates are able to design cost-effective mining systems.

    Performance Criteria
      1) application of engineering economics
      2) understand law of supply and demand
      3) understand global nature of mining industry
      4) understand physical and economics constraints

      Practices
          • design projects
          • majors
          • year-long,senior design project
          • integration into all classes
          • liberal studies program

      Measures
          • student self assessment
          • faculty assessment of design projects
          • alumni self-assessment

      Feedback
          • to faculty from self assesment instruments

    Goal 2
    o Our graduates have an understanding of the interrelationship between mining, permitting and environment

    Performance Criteria
    1) demonstrate concept of mining environmentally friendly
    2) mining methods with least environmental impact
    3) understanding pre-post mining implication on the environment

    Practices
        • problems assigned
        • design projects
        • majors
        • year-long, senior design project

    Measures
        • faculty evaluation of :
        • all design projects
        • problems assigned

    Feedback
        • to students from all projects
        • to faculty, particularly from year long, senior design project

    Goal 3
    o Our graduates have an understanding of mining health and safety issues and governing regulations.

    Performance Criteria
      1) understand geologic condition
      2) understand material capability
      3) understand mine design parameters
      4) understand equipment limitations
      5) understand physical constraints
      6) understanding working environments

      Practices
          • design projects
          • majors
          • year-long, senior design project

      Measures
          • faculty evaluation of all design projects
          • student self-assessment
          • alumni self-assessment

      Feedback

          • to students from all projects
          •to faculty, particularly from senior design project